[sticky entry] Sticky: About & Links

elwinfortuna: Rainbow Fëanorian star, surrounded by text: "through sorrow to find joy." (Default)
"And yet their labour was not all in vain; and though nowhere and in no work was their will and purpose wholly fulfilled, and all things were in hue and shape other than the Valar had at first intended, slowly nonetheless the Earth was fashioned and made firm. And thus was the habitation of the Children of Ilúvatar established at the last in the Deeps of Time and amidst the innumerable stars."
- Ainulindale, The Silmarillion, JRR Tolkien

Innumerable Stars is a Tolkien fandom gift exchange for all works by Tolkien or associated with Middle-earth.

People Who Participate in Innumerable Stars are:
★ Interested in and excited about multiple Tolkien-based canons.
☆ Interested in their fellow fans’ creativity in fanfiction and fanart, and excited to explore their own.
★ Open to creating and receiving any one of a number of different prompts or ideas.

☆ Happy to read and comment on the fanwork(s) they receive with thanks first of all, but also to read and comment on other fanworks in the exchange.

 

People Who Participate in Innumerable Stars will:
★ Generally read and create for a variety of slash, gen, het, adventures, fluff, dark, erotica, worldbuilding, etc.

☆ Create their fanwork following their recipient’s prompts in good faith, and receive the fanwork(s) that have been given to them in good faith also.

★ Also write or draw “treats” for others in the exchange, if their own time and inspiration permits after they have completed their assignment,. These are not required but they add to the fun and excitement of the exchange!

☆ Create their fanwork without the use of AI, be it in writing or art.

 

What Innumerable Stars is NOT:

You do not have to be open to or interested in every type of fanwork to participate.  However, Innumerable Stars is not for anyone interested in just one character, pairing, or scenario. Nor is it for people who find stories or art containing material they are not interested in offensive because it exists. If either of these apply, we wish you well, but this is not the exchange for you.

 

AO3 Collection | Tumblr | LiveJournal RSS Feed
◾ Tags:

[sticky entry] Sticky: Schedule

elwinfortuna: (new worlds to inherit)
2025 schedule is:
Nominations Open: Sunday, 03 August 2025, 8:00 PM UTC
Nominations Close: Sunday, 17 August 2025, 8:00 PM UTC
Sign-ups Open: Sunday, 17 August 2025, 11:59 PM UTC
Sign-ups Close: Sunday, 31 August 2025, 8:00 PM UTC
Assignments Out: Monday, 01 September 2025, 8:00 PM UTC
Assignments Due: Sunday, 05 October 2025, 8:00 PM UTC
Works Revealed: Sunday, 12 October 2025, 8:00 PM UTC
Authors Revealed: Sunday, 19 October 2025, 8:00 PM UTC

Previous years )
grundyscribbling: white stars on a light blue background (stars)
Calling all fans of our "small" fandoms! Many people are aware of Lord of the Rings, The Hobbit, The Silmarillion, and Rings of Power. But there are many more fandoms in Innumerable Stars, and we have a special place in our hearts for the small fandoms.

Last round's promotion of the "small" fandoms was a success. We not only had more nominations for those fandoms, we also had more fanworks for them! So we are planning to do another round of promo posts this year - ideally fresh ones, not just recycling last year’s posts.

We're looking for volunteers willing to write a promo post for one or more of the fandoms on our small fandoms list - meaning any fandom with less than 100 works posted to AO3. We'd also be very excited if anyone wants to promo the fandoms newly added this round - unlike the others, they don't have any posts from previous rounds to fall back on if there are no volunteers.

The promo posts will be posted on Tumblr and Dreamwidth to get people looking at the fandoms in advance of nominations. Your post should answer the following in your own words:
  • Summary - what is this fandom about?
  • Why should I check out this canon?
  • Where can I get this? (The mods are able to assist somewhat with this.)
  • What fanworks exist already? (We have links to the tags on AO3, but people who are into the fandom can probably add a bit more - you probably know better than we do if there is more to be found and where.)
  • Optional: provide an image (The image must be either your own work, or a stock photo/other image that allows posting - no copyrighted images, please.)

Note: If you would like to suggest a fandom to be added to Innumerable Stars, now is the time! We are open to adding fandoms based on material written by Tolkien or media adaptations thereof. (Musicals, operas, movies.) We do not add new fandoms once nominations open.

Our small fandoms list is below. Bolded fandoms are new this year - we really need promo posts for these fandoms! The links in most cases go to the works for the fandom on AO3; in a few cases, they go to the work itself. Please note the numbers were accurate at the time the list was compiled, but it's possible more works may post before nominations begin.

Fandoms List )
grundyscribbling: white stars on a light blue background (stars)
Welcome to Innumerable Stars!

This is our tenth year. We're trying something a bit different this year - we'll do a single brief explainer post, then do separate posts about Nominations and Sign-Ups. (We're trying to make it simple to find the information you need, and easy for people new to the event to get the gist.)

What is Innumerable Stars?
Innumerable Stars is a low-pressure, low-key Tolkien fanworks exchange. The event is run on AO3, so you will need an AO3 account to participate. [personal profile] grundyscribbling  and [personal profile] elwinfortuna  are the event moderators. If you want more of a flavor of the event, see the About & Links post.

What are the key dates?
Nominations Open: Sunday, 03 August 2025, 8:00 PM UTC
Nominations Close: Sunday, 17 August 2025, 8:00 PM UTC
Sign-ups Open: Sunday, 17 August 2025, 11:59 PM UTC
Sign-ups Close: Sunday, 31 August 2025, 8:00 PM UTC
Assignments Due: Sunday, 05 October 2025, 8:00 PM UTC

Our full 2025 schedule is posted here, and in the unlikely event of any changes, that is where updates will be made.

How does Innumerable Stars work?
There are three phases of the event - Nominations, Sign-Ups, and Assignments.

In Nominations, we create the tagset for the exchange by submitting characters, pairings, and worldbuilding elements participants are interested in seeing. The only requirement to participate at this stage is a valid AO3 account. No sign-up is required, and you are not committed to do anything more. There will be a post no later than one week before Nominations open explaining Nominations in full.

In Sign-Ups, participants commit to creating a fanwork, and submit their requests (the things they would like to receive) and offers (things they are willing to create for.) There will be a post no later than one week before Sign-Ups open explaining Sign-ups in full. This post will also cover expectations regarding assignments so that everyone signing up has all information before making requests or offers.

The mods then match the requests and offers, and send out the Assignments. An assignment includes ALL the requests from the participant you are matched with, but you are only required to create for one of them - it is up to you which one. The period to create the fanwork for your assignment is 5 weeks. (The participant you are assigned to create for will not necessarily be creating for you.)

There is a short period after the assignment due date for the mods to ensure all fanworks have been received, and then the collection opens and squeeing commences.

What are the requirements?
  • Fanworks for Innumerable Stars must be a minimum of 500 words or a nice sketch on clean, unlined paper. (Note that we welcome various artistic mediums, so artists, please translate 'nice sketch on clean, unlined paper' to your medium.)
  • Participants must abide by any Do Not Wants listed in their assignment.
  • Participants will create for one of the requests listed in their assignment; it is their choice which one to create for.
  • Participants will comment on the fanwork created for them after the collection opens. If they feel they cannot leave any positive comment, they will bring the issue to the mods.
  • Participants will be respectful of others. This is a welcoming, inclusive event.
  • Fanworks must be the creator's own work, without any use of generative AI, such as MidJourney or ChatGPT.
Why do you post the rules and other key information on Dreamwidth?
Better editorial control - if we need to update a post, we know there aren't versions in circulation that aren't up to date.

Is there a way to get in touch with the mods other than here or Tumblr?
Yes, you can email us, innumerablestars.exchange at Gmail dot com.
◾ Tags:
grundyscribbling: galadriel smiling (Default)

Creators have been revealed!

Recipients, if you have not already done so, please comment on your gift as soon as possible.

If there are any issues, please bring them to the mods.

Thank you to everyone for another fantastic Innumerable Stars - we hope to see you next year for another round!

◾ Tags:
grundyscribbling: white stars on a light blue background (stars)

Utúlie'n aurë! The day has come! The collection is open!

At time of writing, there are 31 works in the collection for your enjoyment. ("At time of writing" as there is no deadline for treats - treats may still be posted at any time.) You are an amazing group of creators!

Recipients - please make sure to comment on your gift(s) to thank your creator(s).

Creators - please bear in mind that not all recipients are able to pounce on their gift and comment immediately, no matter how much they might want to. (We know patience is difficult in this situation, but do your best.)

Everyone - creators love comments! If you like a work in the collection, tell the creator about it.

If there are any questions or issues, please let the mods know. You can drop us an ask on here, comment on DW, find us on Discord, or email us at the collection Gmail address.

◾ Tags:
grundyscribbling: white stars on a light blue background (stars)

All assignments have been turned in. The collection is looking great!

That said, it's not too late for treats. There are a few in the collection already, but there's still time for more. (Everyone loves treats...)

As a reminder, the minimums do not apply to treats. (There is also no deadline, so there is zero pressure. You can still put treats in even after the collection opens.) Anyone can treat, whether signed up for the exchange or not. All requests are viewable in the Requests Summary, and the collection is here - just click 'Post to Collection'.

Treats in the 'smaller' fandoms are particularly welcome - we always love to see more in these fandoms.

grundyscribbling: galadriel smiling (Default)

And the deadline has passed. Thank you to all authors and artists!

There are a couple extensions, but at this point we anticipate that the collection will open on time, Sunday, 13 October 2024, 8:00 PM UTC

If anyone is still feeling inspired, treats - meaning extra gifts - are always welcome. Treats are not subject to the minimum requirements and have no deadline. Anyone can treat, signed up or not. You can find all the requests in the Requests Summary, and the collection is here.

grundyscribbling: galadriel smiling (Default)

REMINDER: Assignments are due 10/06 8PM UTC.

That is roughly 2 hours from time of posting*. If you need a countdown, you can find that here.

If you believe you will not finish on time (or that you will not finish), please talk to the mods now. If you're not sure if you need an extension or to default, we can help you work that out. There is no penalty if you default before the deadline. If you know you need an extension, please do not wait until a couple minutes before the deadline to let us know.

Treats - meaning extra gifts - are always welcome. Anyone can treat, signed up or not. If you see a prompt you love and would like to create something for it, go for it! (Treats are not subject to the minimum requirements and have no deadline.) If you think you might like to treat, you can find all the requests in the Requests Summary, and the collection is here.

*this was meant to post 12 hours ago, when there would have been more time, but for reasons known only unto DW went to my account instead of the IS community.
◾ Tags:
grundyscribbling: galadriel smiling (Default)

Reminder: assignments are due Sunday, 06 October 2024, 8:00 PM UTC That is one week from today!

If you think you will be unable to complete your assignment, please talk to the mods now. If you need to default, we will not guilt or blame you - we just want to get the call for a pinch hit out ASAP. We want to make sure everyone receives something so the collection can open on time. There is no penalty whatsoever if you default before the deadline. (That said, we'd rather you not wait until two minutes before to acknowledge things aren't working out. We want to give any pinch hitter as much time as we can.)

Treats - meaning extra gifts - are always welcome, and anyone can create them, signed up or not. If you see a prompt you love and would like to create something for it, go for it! (Treats are not subject to the minimum requirements and have no deadline.) If you think you might like to treat, you can find all the requests in the Requests Summary, and the collection is here.

◾ Tags:
grundyscribbling: white stars on a light blue background (stars)

Assignments are out! Check your inbox or your AO3 dash.

We hope you're as excited as we are - there are some fabulous prompts. Go forth and create!

Anyone who has a placeholder Dear Creator letter - please make sure it is finished and available by Thursday. (The first thing most creators do is look at that letter - if you don’t have it done now, get it done ASAP!)

Minimum requirement is 500 words (authors) or a nice sketch on clean, unlined paper (artists).

If it looks like you will be unable to complete your assignment for some reason, please default as soon as you are sure and let the mods know! This allows us as much time as possible to arrange a pinch hit. There is no penalty for defaulting before the due date.

Any pinch hits will be posted here as soon as we know about them.

Treats - meaning extra gifts - are always welcome, and anyone can create them, signed up or not. If you see a prompt you love and would like to create something for it, go for it! (Treats are not subject to the minimum requirements and have no deadline.) If you think you might like to treat, you can find all the requests in the Requests Summary, and the collection is here.

◾ Tags:
elwinfortuna: Gandalf in front of the Doors of Durin. (Gandalf Doors of Durin)
Our tagset for 2024 is complete and ready to go!

Once you've read through the Signups Info Post, it's time to sign up! Even if you participate every year, please be sure to review the information post.

This year, in any fandom with more than 50 character tags, offering "Any Character" requires mod approval. These fandoms are:
The Lord of the Rings - J. R. R. Tolkien
The Silmarillion
Crossover Fandom

Any first-time participants should avoid offering "Any Character" in these fandoms, as it will most likely not be approved.

If you have any questions, please comment here on DW, contact us on Discord, or send a Tumblr ask (bearing in mind that we are still not reliably getting notifications about asks on Tumblr, though this appears to be working better this year).

Signups will close on Sunday, 1 September at 8:00 PM UTC.
◾ Tags:
elwinfortuna: Rainbow Fëanorian star, surrounded by text: "through sorrow to find joy." (Default)
Nominations are now closed.

If you notice anything incorrect or any duplicates, please let us know as soon as possible.

Signups will open soon following a final check of the tagset.
◾ Tags:
grundyscribbling: white stars on a light blue background (stars)

We had two new to us fandoms nominated.

We are thrilled to discover them, but unfortunately, we cannot include them in this round of IS. We do not add new fandoms midway or more through the nominations period. We will be happy to add Eärendilova Plavba (Eärendil's Voyage musical) and Horn of Gondor (fan film) to the next round of IS, and hope that whoever nominated them will be willing to write up promo posts so we can get the word out about these fandoms prior to nominations.

This also goes for other fandoms not currently in IS - we do not object to adding fandoms, but we prefer to add them before nominations open. And we will not add new fandoms more than 5 days into nominations - it's not only unfair to anyone who gets their nominations in early, it means people who are not already familiar with the fandom won't have adequate time to look into it before sign-ups. (Remember nominations are only how we form the tagset - people still need to offer/request things!)

◾ Tags:
grundyscribbling: white stars on a light blue background (stars)
Once the tag set is complete, sign-ups will open. This is the stage where you commit to participating in the exchange. By signing up, you are saying you will created a fanwork for another participant assigned to you. Someone will also be assigned to create a fanwork for you.

Sign-Ups )

Dear Creator Letters )

Matching )

Assignments )

Defaults & Pinch Hits )

Request From The Mods About Wordcounts )
◾ Tags:
grundyscribbling: white stars on a light blue background (stars)

We are halfway through nominations!

The tagset is looking great, and we know there are still plenty of nominations yet to come.

For those who haven't done nominations yet, or who still have slots left, the following fandoms have zero nominations at time of writing:

  • Adventures in Middle-earth (Roleplaying Game)
  • Hunt for Gollum (2009)
  • Mr. Bliss - J. R. R. Tolkien
  • The Notion Club Papers
  • The Hobbit (Jackson Movies)

There are also several fandoms that have a few nominations, but we'd be happy to see more:

  • Born of Hope (2009)
  • Leaf by Niggle - J. R. R. Tolkien
  • Pearl - J. R. R. Tolkien
  • Sellic Spell - J. R. R. Tolkien
  • The Lord of the Rings Online
  • The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power
◾ Tags:
grundyscribbling: white stars on a light blue background (stars)

Nominations are open!

Please make sure you've read the Nominations info post so your nominations can be approved quickly.

Once you've done that, the tagset is here. (Remember to copy-paste the fandom names!) Go forth and nominate!

◾ Tags:
hhimring: Estel, inscription by D. Salo (Default)
Summary:

The Fall of Arthur is a narrative poem in alliterative metre by Tolkien. It takes elements from different Arthurian works and sources and recombines them in a way that is all Tolkien's own. As the title says, the subject is the collapse of Arthur's rule through betrayal and his death. It is not complete but reached quite a fair length (a bit less than 1000 lines, in 5 cantos), and there are some of Tolkien's working notes for the unwritten end included in the edition.

Why should I check out this canon:

As a kind of crossover, this work is likely to be especially interesting to those who have an interest in Arthur, Gawain, and the other Arthurian characters more generally. Tolkien is partly inspired by some less well-known medieval sources, so it may be a fresh angle on Arthurian lore to readers for that reason, too. Particularly interesting and original is the complex shading of Tolkien's portrait of Guinevere. The work will also appeal to those who like Tolkien's other narrative poems or read works in modern alliterative verse. There is some great storm imagery and description in there, for instance. The piece is also interesting as demonstrating one of the sources of inspiration for Tolkien that have received less attention than the Germanic tradition. The poem work could both inspire further Arthuriana and crossovers with Tolkien’s non-Arthurian works.

Where can I get this?

This is one of the lesser-known works of Tolkien, partly because it was published quite late, even though its existence was known much earlier. The text is available in a hardcover edition, with a significant amount of supplementary material for those who wish to delve deeper. An electronic copy of this is also available on the Internet Archive to those with print disabilities. It is also possible to get a taster by hunting down some substantial quotations online, as the online reviews that appeared on its publication tend to do a fair amount of quoting.

What fanworks already exist?

There are currently six works in the AO3 tag, of which four are crossovers with other Tolkien works (one is a poem) and one is a moodboard.
◾ Tags:
grundyscribbling: white stars on a light blue background (stars)

(written by [personal profile] dawn_felagund )

Summary:
Tolkien began writing the "Silmarillion" as a young man in the trenches of World War I. The Book of Lost Tales are the stories he penned during this period of his life and represent his earliest work on the "Silmarillion." Many of the familiar tales are already present in their early form: the cosmic conflict between the Valar and Melkor, the tale of Beren and Lúthien, and the Fall of Gondolin, to name just three. These stories are embedded in a frame narrative where the Anglo-Saxon mariner Eriol ends up visiting Eressëa and hearing a series of stories from the Elven residents there. The Lost Tales were never finished in their entirety, so while some of the early stories are complete, others are fragmentary or just outlines. Each tale is accompanied by commentary from Christopher Tolkien, who edited the collection.

Why Should I Check Out This Canon? The Lost Tales are recognizably "Silmarillion" stories, yet they differ greatly in style and tone from Tolkien's later work. They are more whimsical and more like the Victorian fairy-stories that Tolkien later denigrated. Magical elements abound, and the texts are more playful than the more sober "Silmarillion" texts Tolkien would write in the decades to come. In addition, they contain copious detail, especially about the Valar and Maiar, their homes in Valinor, and their adventures against Melkor.

For creators who work with the published Silmarillion, the Lost Tales can provide canon details that expand what is available in The Silmarillion (Nienna lives in a hall constructed of bat wings!) or deviate from it in surprising and delightful ways (Sauron is the prince of cats!)

Where Can I Get This? The Book of Lost Tales comprise the first two volumes of the History of Middle-earth series. They are available as both print and ebooks. For a reader not up for two volumes of sometimes dense reading, individual stories stand well on their own.

What Fanworks Already Exist? There is no tag on AO3 specifically for The Book of Lost Tales. Creators use several different Tolkien tags to mark these works. On AO3, you may have luck finding Lost Tales fanworks here. The #book of lost tales tag on Tumblr has more fanworks.

grundyscribbling: white stars on a light blue background (stars)

(Written by Aprilertuile)

Summary: Born of Hope tells us the meeting and love story of Arathorn and Gilraen, who would later become the parents of Aragorn, at a difficult time when Sauron’s power is growing and the orcs are looking for the Dúnedain, and more specifically, for the heir of Isildur.

Why should you check this fandom: If you liked the Lord of the Rings, you should really check this movie. It’s fan made, and very well made, it has the Dúnedain’s recent history, orcs, danger, impressive skirmishes, the wilderness of Middle Earth, Elladan and Elrohir and also... Baby Estel.

Where can I get this? Born of Hope is available here : Born of Hope - Lord of the Rings fan film prequel

What fanworks exist already?

There are 9 fanworks on AO3. The fanfictions are nice to read to continue the adventure.

narya_flame: Young woman drinking aperol in Venice (Default)
Summary:  Like Sir Orfeo and Sir Gawain, this is a late Middle English poem (written in a North-West Midlands dialect of Middle English).  A grieving father experiences a dream-vision of a beautiful maiden.  She tries to explain the glories of heaven to him, but he cannot comprehend them, and on trying to join her, he wakes up.  He is left consoled and reflecting on his faith.

Tolkien encountered the poem as a student, and both taught and translated it as a scholar.  Its elegiac tone will feel familiar to fans of Tolkien’s work, and while the text itself is dense, it’s well worth reading, re-reading and unpacking.

 
Why should I check out this canon:  If you’re interested in the texts Tolkien read and absorbed, and how they shaped the tone and content of his mythology, this is definitely one for your list. It’s is a smaller, more reflective Tolkien text: there's no cast of thousands, no epic adventures, but still plenty to explore. Who sent the Dream Vision? Who is the Pearl Poet – are they also the Gawain poet, or are they someone else? Is the poem an elegy, an allegory, both? Something completely different? Where is the Pearl-maiden, what is her name, and what are the circumstances where the boundaries between life and death might thin to allow for communication?
 
I think this text lends itself beautifully to unusual fanwork formats, so if that’s your thing, definitely get hold of a copy!  You could potentially go for some in-universe meta here (people much brighter than me have pointed out that part of the poem reads like a lapidary). For art, you could try out something like a medieval illumination, or an illustration in the style of a stained glass window - or calligraphy of a passage you particularly like.  If you’re into the idea of Middle-earth crossovers, there’s plenty of pearl imagery in the legendarium to provide you with links, from Alqualondë to the Sleeper in the Tower of Pearl (some online scholars have even found connections between the narrator and Gollum!)
 
 
Where can I get this?  Sir Gawain and the Green Knight, together with Pearl and Sir Orfeo was first published in 1975, so there are several editions available – try your preferred bookshop, online retailer, or public library.  The 1975 edition is available as a PDF on the Internet Archive.  There is also a free copy of Tolkien's translation on Allpoetry.com.
 

What fanworks already exist?  None that I could find!  You could be first!
 
elwinfortuna: (adventure tristan)
Summary

One of Tolkien's most obscure and unfinished works, The Notion Club Papers came about as the result of an agreement with his friend C S Lewis. Lewis took on the challenge of writing a space-travel story, which became his Space Trilogy, whereas Tolkien was clearly all in on Middle-earth at the time and never made it very far into his time-travel story.

The end result that we have is two versions of the beginning of what could have been a much larger tale, consisting of fragments and a somewhat puzzling narrative along with characters clearly based on (admittedly!) the Inklings themselves. The story itself, what exists of it, gives hints of H G Wells' The Time Machine, Charlie Stross' Laundry Files, or, naturally, C S Lewis and his Space Trilogy, to which it is at least partially a response.

Why Should I Check Out This Canon?

I think there is honestly so much untapped potential here for both writers and artists, however, it's probably not to everyone's taste. But if you like the Inklings themselves and would be intrigued by a fictional version, if you like the idea of piecing together fragments of a larger work, if you're inspired to fill in gaps and explore dark recesses, if you're wondering how Tolkien would have perceived the future (1980s-1990s and 2012), or if you're a fan of Aelfwine, then have a look and see what you make of it!

Where Can I Get This?

This is only available in The History of Middle-earth, Volume 9, Sauron Defeated, and makes up the second half of the volume. It was published in the 1990s and is probably available in your local library or bookshop, though it might have to be special-ordered. If you cannot get hold of it another way, please get in touch with me (edgeoflight) / elwinfortuna and I'll arrange to get you a copy.

What Fanworks Already Exist?

Nothing, nada, zilch! If you want to break some new ground here, you absolutely can.
◾ Tags:

About

innumerable_stars: rainbow stars with mountains underneath (Default)
Innumerable Stars: a Tolkien fanworks exchange

June 2025

S M T W T F S
12345 67
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
2930     

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags